• Meet Our Family
  • Florida Life
  • Home Tour

Our Potluck Family

  • FAMILY
    • Marriage
    • Kids
    • Pets
    • Adventures
    • Fitness
  • FOOD
    • Appetizers
    • Beverages
    • Desserts
    • Meal Ideas
    • Nutrition
  • DIY
    • Kid Crafts
    • Gardening
    • Holiday Crafts
    • Paper Crafts
    • Sewing Projects
    • Technology
    • Home Decor
  • ENTERTAIN
    • Adult Parties
    • Kid Parties
    • Family Parties
    • Holiday Parties
  • CONTACT & PR
  • Privacy Policy

March.19.2014 · 2 Comments

Teaching Subtraction Using Manipulatives

Posts

Sharing is caring!

0shares
  • Share
  • Tweet

I actually took these photos right after the whole What Common Core is NOT controversy, but decided to wait until now to post it. The big argument that everyone had regarding the following math problem is that we should just ‘subtract down’ as we always did.

IMG_6403

With this particular problem, it appears as though that can be done. We don’t have to borrow from a different column, so we can follow a simple algorithm. That’s all great… until problems get more complex, and children do not understand the rationale behind borrowing (that you are taking one group of 10 and breaking it into individual 1’s to be able to subtract).

So here’s this simple problem, using one method to solve it using manipulatives.

IMG_6402

Children need to understand place value to recognize why we subtract in the manner in which we subtract.

IMG_6391

A lot of people told me to just subtract 2 – 2 and 3 – 1. Well, that’s not even the problem that’s being presented. Here is why.

IMG_6385

This is what 32 actually looks like.

IMG_6384

Then we must do the same thing with 12.

IMG_6392

IMG_6386

Now we can actually solve the problem. Begin with the right column – directionality does not appear to matter in this problem, but it will matter when you have to borrow in future problems. Better to teach the right way from the beginning!

IMG_6397

Move to the left column. This required two sheets of paper.

IMG_6394

IMG_6395

So now we can actually understand and solve the problem correctly. Does it appear to be a lot of extra steps? Sure! but will it help children to have a deeper understanding of what we’re actually doing, rather than teaching them to follow a simple algorithm, that long works for this specific type of problem? Absolutely!

IMG_6398

Related Posts

  • Common Core Math Standards in ActionCommon Core Math Standards in Action
  • Teaching One-to-one Correspondence to PreschoolersTeaching One-to-one Correspondence to Preschoolers
  • Thanksgiving Math ActivitiesThanksgiving Math Activities
  • Apple Exploration for Young Kids {PRINTABLES}Apple Exploration for Young Kids {PRINTABLES}

Related

« Kids Craft: Paper Fox Mask
Gluten-free, Calorie-free Miracle Noodles »

Comments

  1. Jim Lambert says

    March.28.2015 at 8:51 pm

    I came across the original graphic on Facebook and followed a link to your original ‘Core’ article. I wanted to point out an assumption you made in this demonstration: “Begin with the right column” and your statement to teach the right way (because of the possibility of borrowing in subtraction).

    A few years ago I picked up an abacus and learned the basics of how to use it. Abacus subtraction starts on the left and works to the right, the final subtraction being the ‘ones column’. This allows you to ‘borrow’ from the final result of subtracting earlier columns, rather than ‘borrowing’ from one of the numbers before performing further subtraction on it. I won’t say it’s better, although it has advantages with the abacus, but it shows that our right way may not be the only or even best way.

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. What Common Core is NOT | Huppie Mama says:
    March.19.2014 at 7:11 am

    […] By providing a step-by-step task analysis, you can teach children the WHY? behind that process. Click here for a visual representation of Methodology #1. Here’s my revised version, comparing “old” and “new” that shows all […]

    Reply

Any Comments? Cancel reply

Carrie + Richard are a dynamic wife + husband blogging team, raising two children in North Florida. Topics of interest include recipes, crafts, entertaining, and family fun!

This error message is only visible to WordPress admins

Error: No connected account.

Please go to the Instagram Feed settings page to connect an account.

CHECK OUT THESE FAVORITES

  • Sourdough Cinnamon Roll Instagram Sourdough Cinnamon Roll Recipe
  • paper plate penguin kids craft Paper Plate Penguin
  • Egg Carton Wreath Easter Craft
  • Pork Shoulder Roast recipe & Caribbean Dinner Ideas

FREE E-BOOK DOWNLOAD

Learn about Nature e-book

  • FAMILY
  • FOOD
  • DIY
  • ENTERTAIN
  • CONTACT & PR
  • Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2021 · captivating theme by Restored 316