Some blog posts I get super excited to write, like a fun new craft or recipe. This one… not so much. I came up with the title at least a year ago, knowing that one day, this would happen. I would be here. Here was a really scary place. I cried about it numerous times in public and private. I thoroughly dreaded the day it would happen, and I wondered how I would handle it. And now we’re here. And it’s just as scary as I thought it would be. So much so that I can’t just write the words. But I must.
I will never breastfeed again.
That was painful. Super painful. I will never breastfeed again. I’m done. Life has taught me that sometimes the things we most strongly oppose at one point in life can be our most driven passions later on in life. Parenting graces us with an identity we never realized we would experience. When you’re getting ultrasounds and registering for strollers and carseats and stuffing your face with ‘food for two’, you have this lofty idea that parenting is about adding a new addition to your family, someone to love on limitlessly, someone to stick in cute clothing and photograph.
And then your baby is born, and the reality of caring for this being that was just a part of your body, but now exists outside of you, can be truly overwhelming. Prior to having children, I had a large lumpectomy in my right breast, had a breast augmentation, a lift on my left side, and a correction to the left when the implant started to bottom out. I assumed I would be unable to breastfeed, and I kinda didn’t care since I grew up thinking it was somehow wrong or disgusting. But when I realized my body was producing colostrum, I knew I wanted to give her colostrum. That was really my only breastfeeding goal in advance: a week of breastfeeding.
But honestly, from the moment Lydia was born, I instantly forgot about all that I had thought I wanted to do and all of the gadgets I registered for and the cute outfits and hair bows. I was in survival mode. How do I care for this being that my body nurtured for almost 10 months? How do I keep her alive and safe? And at that point, the only thing I wanted to do was breastfeed this baby. Around the clock. Whenever she wanted it. Until she no longer wanted to nurse.
Lydia weaned herself, cold-turkey, at about 14.5 months. I did not encourage her to give it up. She honestly woke up one morning and had no interest in nursing anymore. A few weeks later, I was pregnant with Bryce.
I promised Bryce 14.5 months, just like his sister. I promised myself that I would have the patience to embark on this journey once again. A year of this incredibly powerful symbiotic relationship. Women who choose not to breastfeed their babies or who are unable to for whatever reason miss what I believe to be the most beautiful part of nurturing a newborn, infant, and toddler: the powerful relationship breastfeeding creates. When you are a work-from-home mom who breastfeeds, your child is often attached to your body hours and hours every day. Every 30 minutes, 30 minutes at a time, all day and night. If he wasn’t nursing, not only did he feel it, but I felt it, too. I did not pump for Bryce. He took ONE 2-ounce bottle once so I could go get a haircut on my birthday when he was about 7 weeks old. Every other drop of breastmilk this child received came directly from my body to his.
Take note, I have in no way referred to breastmilk and breastfeeding as food or eating. Anyone can feed a baby. Modern advances have allowed mothers to physically detach from their young starting at birth. Breastfeeding is what allows the modern mother and baby to connect with what nature has decided is right for us to survive as a species. It is the most brilliant expression of our creator’s understanding of the life we have been given. It is a true blessing, allowing our adult bodies to nurture our babies after they have exited the womb.
It has always been pretty clear to my husband (not so much me) that we are only having two children. When you know this, you realize that each moment is your last. Your last pregnancy, last birthing experience, last time holding your newborn, last time seeing all the firsts (first birthday, first words, first steps), and last child to nurse.
The last time Bryce nursed was the day after his 3rd birthday. I breastfed him for 36 months.
It’s been about 6 weeks since he stopped, and I finally have the courage now to write about it. All my children have weaned. As much as I have whined about my children’s poor sleeping habits over the years, I am incredibly grateful that even though Bryce has weaned, he still comes in my bed every single night to snuggle with me. He gets close to my body, looks into my eyes, and his little body still shows me how much he loves me. With tears in my eyes, this is my reminder to never forgot how important the bond that breastfeeding created for us has been to our lives.
These choices we make as parents – every single one – they shape our identity. They create advocates and friendships. They polarize and unify. They cause us to be insanely intuitive and confidently uncertain. My greatest fear when I contemplated Bryce’s choice to wean was that I would lose my identity. But now I know, the choice I made to breastfeed and naturally wean my children created an identity for myself I will never lose.
My emotions and body are both eternally grateful.
Paula @ Frosted Fingers says
I made it 6, 12, and 18 months with the first 3. We will see what happens with Q. I love what you wrote.
Dr. Carrie Wells says
Thank you so much, Paula. Such a hard post to write, but I am so grateful for the years I was able to nurse both my children.
MamalDiane says
Wow, that was an amazing post. Thank you so much for sharing your beautiful experiences and photos. My daughter breast fed both of my grandchildren for as long as they desired it. It was the most beautiful natural thing in the world to observe. The picture of you and your two children brought tears to my eyes it was so beautiful 🙂
MamaLuvsBooks says
I miss it too! I loved breastfeeding my kids. My son NEVER took a bottle. We tried but he would not do it! He lasted 22 months. My daughter quit herself at 11 months! =)
Krista says
Love this! I’m breastfeeding as I read it and it reminds me to enjoy every moment I have because this is my last child!
Dr. Carrie Wells says
Definitely, Krista!! Enjoy it all.
Dr. Carrie Wells says
We’re so fortunate to be work-at-home moms so we didn’t have to worry about our boys not taking bottles.
Blondiemomma says
I am nearing the end with my second (and final) child. He turned 4 in September and he’s pretty nearly done. He nurses a few minutes to go to bed, but not every night any more. Our time is almost over….and I am sad and overwhelmed and so thrilled with our journey! How could I not be? I didn’t make it half as far as I had hoped with my first, so I was more determined (and knowledgeable!) when #2 came along. My original goal has been quadrupled this time around!
Beautiful story. I have been reading several similar tales lately and they really tug at my heartstrings!
Tracy says
Powerful article. I agree that nursing nourishes the mind and body. It is hard to convince people that the emotional needs of infants are real.
Breast Is Blessed says
I notice you say your first weaned at 14.5 months. And then there was a picture underneath that of a toddler thumbsucking. I assume it was the same child. Did you know that Kathy Dettwyler (anthropologist who had deemed the natural age of weaning to be 2-7 years in humans) has said in all of her research as an anthropolgist thumbsucking is absent in other cultures. It is very rare for a child to wean before 2 years own on their own. You may have allowed thumbsucking, which IS a replacement for the breast, and the child developed a preference for that. Some children have a natural disposition to thumbsuck and may have done it in the womb. When my second and third children were born the attempted to do so, and I had to gently direct them to the breast until they understood. I just say this so others may benefit from this knowledge. I let my oldest thumsuck for about a full year. At that point, I learned about nursing on demand and he was old enough to start pointing at my breasts when he wanted to nurse. I started nursing him on demand one day, and from that exact moment forward he never sucked his thumb every again. I felt really bad about not meeting his needs before and wish I had known sooner how it can interfere with the breastfeeding relationship.
Breast Is Blessed says
Also, a child quitting cold turkey is usually a nursing strike and not natural weaning—which is a slow gradual process. 🙂
Lukrecija Kilė says
Your confession moved me to tears!
Julie Robbins says
I thought I was also done at 2 and low and behold after 21 years of marriage, ages 42 and 45 along came our boy. It was beautiful, and magical, and soo soo good. Both of my eldest daughters nursed almost 18 mos, and sadly, my lack of understanding of breastfeeding both times led me to believe this was the age to wean, but when my boy came alone, I simply thought, let Daniel decide. well, at 3 and 1/2 years he decided. and I did blog about it. bitter sweet, and yes, I am also glad he climbs in our bed at 4 and 1/2 yrs. to snuggle.
Dr. Carrie Wells says
That’s amazing, Julie! I am sure it’s a completely different experience being a mother again many years later.
Chelley Martinka says
I’m crying. I never want this relationship to end.
Gena says
I absolutely love this post. Everything about it. I am currently bfing our last baby and he’s almost two. As much as it’s going to be sad when he stops, I know it’s a part of life. Thank you for sharing!!